When it comes to protecting valuable equipment in harsh environments, two names consistently rise to the top: Pelican and SKB. Whether you're a photographer venturing into extreme conditions, a musician touring with expensive instruments, or a professional who needs to transport sensitive equipment, choosing the right protective case is crucial. Let's dive into a comprehensive comparison of these industry leaders to help you make an informed decision.
The History of Protection
Pelican Products has been manufacturing high-performance pelican protective cases since 1976. Founded by Dave Parker, the company started with a focus on dive equipment but quickly expanded into protective cases for various industries. Today, Pelican is synonymous with rugged protection in fields ranging from military and law enforcement to photography and outdoor adventures.
SKB Corporation, established in 1977, began producing guitar cases in a small garage in California. Over the decades, they've expanded their product line to include the renowned SKB storage case solutions for military, industrial, and consumer applications. Their innovation in injection-molded cases has made them a formidable competitor in the protective case market.
Materials and Construction
Pelican Protective Case Technology
The pelican protective case is typically manufactured using a proprietary blend of polypropylene copolymer. This material offers exceptional impact resistance while maintaining relatively light weight. The cases feature a cell-core construction with open cells in the interior and solid walls on the exterior, creating a structure that absorbs shock without compromising strength.
Most Pelican cases come with their patented double-throw latches, which ensure a secure seal while being easy to open when needed. The automatic pressure equalization valve allows air to flow in and out of the case when pressure changes occur, preventing vacuum lock while maintaining water resistance.
SKB Storage Case Design
An SKB storage case is often made from ultra-high-strength polypropylene copolymer resin. This material undergoes a proprietary molding process that SKB claims provides superior impact resistance. The cases feature molded-in hinges that enhance durability by eliminating potential failure points common in cases with separate hinge components.
SKB's trigger release latching system provides both security and ease of access. Many SKB cases also incorporate their patented "trigger release" system, which allows for one-handed operation—a feature particularly appreciated by professionals who need quick access to their equipment.
Waterproof Performance
When you need a best waterproof case, both manufacturers offer impressive options. Pelican cases feature a continuous neoprene or polymer O-ring that creates a watertight seal when the case is closed. Most Pelican cases are rated IP67, meaning they can be submerged in water up to 1 meter deep for 30 minutes without leakage.
SKB also offers waterproof cases with their exclusive "Mil-Std" gasket system. Many SKB cases meet or exceed the IP67 rating, making them suitable for various water-related applications. When choosing the best waterproof case for your specific needs, consider not just the IP rating but also the design of the seal and the latching mechanism.
Interior Customization
A pelican protective case typically comes with several interior options:
- Pick-and-pluck foam (pre-scored foam that can be customized by hand)
- Padded dividers (adjustable compartments for organization)
- TrekPak divider system (a newer option with customizable rigid dividers)
- Empty cases for custom solutions
The SKB storage case line offers similar options but often includes their proprietary "Diced Foam" system, which provides excellent equipment protection while allowing for customization. SKB also offers specialized interiors for specific equipment types, such as their "Think Tank" designs for photographers.
Specialized Applications
Photography and Videography
Photographers and videographers often prefer the pelican protective case for its wide range of sizes and interior customization options. The Pelican 1510 has become something of an industry standard because it fits airline carry-on dimensions while providing maximum protection.
SKB offers strong competition with their iSeries cases, many of which are designed specifically for camera equipment. These cases often feature custom foam inserts designed for specific camera models, making them ready to use right out of the box.
Musical Equipment
Musicians have long favored the SKB storage case for instruments due to their early specialization in guitar cases. SKB offers molded cases for specific instrument types, from guitars and basses to drums and keyboards.
Pelican has entered this market with their high-performance cases, which many touring professionals now use for delicate equipment. The best waterproof case for musical equipment often depends on the specific instrument and touring conditions.
Military and Tactical Applications
Both companies manufacture cases that meet military specifications. Pelican's line of military-grade cases has been field-tested in extreme conditions around the world. The pelican protective case is often used for weapons, communications equipment, and sensitive electronic devices.
SKB's military cases offer similar protection levels and are widely used by armed forces globally. Their injection-molded tactical cases are designed to withstand the rigors of field operations while providing quick access to critical equipment.
Price Comparison
Generally, Pelican cases tend to be slightly more expensive than comparable SKB models, though this varies by specific case size and features. When considering the investment in a best waterproof case, remember that both brands offer lifetime warranties on many of their products, making them long-term investments in equipment protection.
Making Your Decision
When choosing between a pelican protective case and an SKB storage case, consider these factors:
- Specific equipment needs: Some specialized equipment may fit better in one brand's cases than the other.
- Usage conditions: Will you be frequently submerging the case, or is splash resistance sufficient?
- Weight considerations: Pelican cases are typically slightly lighter than comparable SKB models.
- Interior customization: Both offer excellent options, but one may better suit your specific organization needs.
- Budget: While both represent significant investments, price differences might influence your decision.
Conclusion
Both Pelican and SKB produce exceptional protective cases that serve their purpose admirably. The best waterproof case for your needs will depend on your specific equipment, usage scenarios, and personal preferences.
For photographers and videographers working in extreme conditions, the Pelican 1500 or 1510 models offer trusted protection that has become an industry standard. Musicians might find the specialized designs of SKB cases better suited to their instruments. Military and tactical users often select based on specific size requirements and organizational needs.
Whichever brand you choose, investing in a high-quality protective case from either Pelican or SKB ensures your valuable equipment remains safe and functional, even in the most challenging environments.